Question Bank

May 5, 2018 @ 3:00 am
Question Bank

5 MAY 2018


(1 Question)

Answer questions in NOT MORE than 200 words each. Content of the answer is more important than its length.

Links are provided for reference. You can also use the Internet fruitfully to further enhance and strengthen your answers.



Q1. The Windrush scandal has brought to light how the tightened immigration rules have affected people from the commonwealth nations like India. Comment.


  • The Windrush generation were migrants from the Commonwealth Caribbean who came to Britain before 1973(1971 legislation no longer gave them automatic settlement after that date). Along with others from the Commonwealth, they and their families were encouraged to Britain to help meet acute labour shortages, whether in the National Health Service (NHS) or beyondToughening of immigration rules has led to them being penalised and wrongly treated as undocumented illegal immigrants. Shocking stories of families being separated, unable to return to Britain from holidays abroad, denials of life-saving treatment have abounded in recent weeks. While the stories have mostly centred on those from the Caribbean, there are fears that migrants from across the Commonwealth will inevitably have been impacted. The scandal also includes those who came from many other Commonwealth countries, including India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and countries in West Africa.
  • The government — while apologising for the treatment of the Windrush generation and promising acting including compensation — has attempted to treat it as an aberration that had no link with its wider immigration policies. It has tried to make the case that its obsession with cutting migration targets and dealing with illegal migration had nothing whatsoever to do with what had happened
  • These efforts to separate have proved fruitless amid further revelations around the treatment of people legally in Britain or attempting to get to its shores. It emerged that at least a hundred, and potentially more, Indian doctors who had been recruited by NHS trusts up and down the country to fill sorely needed positions, mostly in emergency medicine, had been unable to take up their positions because of visa issues. It was revealed that Prime Minister Theresa May herself had rejected calls for an easing of the visa rules for non-EU doctors.
  • For many years now the British government has been attempting to deport foreign students (and others) based on allegations that they had committed fraud to obtain the English-language qualifications to stay in the U.K.
  • National Indian Students and Alumni Union U.K., which has been campaigning on behalf students who have faced accusations of fraud believes a significant population from India has been impacted. The government has a “deport first, appeal later” strategy, which came into effect around the time students began to face these difficulties, meant there was little recourse open to the studentsThe burden of proof — and blame — was swiftly placed on the shoulders of the students rather than the Home Office-approved system that had allowed the fraud to happen. The same applied to past attempts to cull “bogus colleges’.
  • Separately, a burgeoning group of South Asians are campaigning against what they believe is a misuse of a clause in legislation to prevent the settlement of criminals. The clause is being used to deny IT professionals, doctors and others long resident in the U.K. the indefinite leave to remain because of minor errors in their tax returns. Hundreds are believed to be impacted.

Leave a comment